LONDON – Consumers give higher negative ratings to traditional cable, satellite and IPTV pay-TV operators than online video-on-demand (VOD) providers such as Netflix, Amazon and Hulu at every stage of the customer journey, according to new research from subscription, billing and customer relationship management (CRM) specialist Paywizard.
Nonetheless, the figures reveal that over-the-top (OTT) subscription services also struggle to keep customers happy, receiving significant negative scores at each contact point in the customer journey.
The survey of more than 3,000 consumers across three bellwether markets – the United Kingdom, the United States and the Philippines – reveals that, when it comes handling every major interaction a subscriber experiences when engaging with a pay-TV service, consumers were more negative in their view of traditional pay-TV operators than OTT providers.
The top three interactions identified as the most negative by customers for both traditional and OTT services is a billing issue, with 26% of respondents unhappy about the way an inaccurate bill or payment problem was dealt with – followed by cancelling a subscription (22%) and contacting customer service (21%).
Respondents to the survey also give OTT providers higher positive ratings in eight out of 10 categories – from making sign-up easy, to recommending content, to dealing with billing, to facilitating service cancellation.
There were only two areas in which traditional operators perform better in consumer eyes than OTT rivals in terms of providing a positive experience: contacting customer service (58% versus 51%) and upgrading/downgrading their package (56% to 53%).
Bhavesh Vaghela, Paywizard’s Chief Executive, noted: “There is a perception in the TV market that OTT providers are performing much better than their traditional counterparts, however this research clearly demonstrates that OTT providers are far from perfect and are, in fact, only just better in many key areas of the customer journey.
Overall, joining a service was the part of the customer journey most frequently flagged as a positive experience by subscribers to both traditional pay-TV (68%) and pay-OTT (77%) services.
Dealing with an inaccurate bill or a payment issue was identified by 29% of consumers with a traditional pay-TV subscription and 22% of those taking an OTT service as the interaction most often seen as a negative experience.
Other key findings include:
- Consumers in the Philippines were especially harsh in their scoring of a billing or payment issue with 42% of traditional pay-TV subscribers giving a negative rating and 36% of those with OTT services – nearly double the figures for the US and UK;
- UK consumers were the most favourable towards traditional pay-TV operators, rating them more highly for positive experiences than OTT services in four categories – compared to just two for the US and none for the Philippines;
- The scores – both positive and negative – of younger consumers were, in general, significantly more pronounced than those of older demographics for the US and UK, but for the Philippines there was far less of a divergence between younger and older respondents.
“This research looks at how consumers view their experiences with all pay-TV providers, touching on each Decision Moment in the customer journey,” said Vaghela. “These Decision Moments are the key points at which the performance of an operator can determine how a customer views a service and whether their relationship with the provider will strengthen, weaken or even break.”
He concluded: “We can see that there are slight variations between the markets we surveyed, but what is most clear is that the situation is broadly that same across the board: Traditional pay-TV providers have a lot of work to do to ensure a positive customer experience, and OTT services cannot take it for granted that their subscribers are happy at each point of consumer engagement.”
Decision Moments addresses the critical pay-TV subscriber engagement points most likely to evoke positive or negative emotional reactions and to impact relationships between operators and subscribers during the customer journey.
The eight consumer Decision Moments identified by Paywizard and validated by independent research commissioned by the company are:
1) ‘Find’: Deciding on a service to sign up to, that best suits the consumer’s content and cost requirements
2) ‘Join’: The process of signing up, as easily and quickly as possible
3) ‘Consume’: Seamless viewing of appealing content, at any time, location and on any device
4) ‘Upgrade’: Flexibly upgrading your services package, as and when you like
5) ‘Downgrade’: Flexibly downgrading your services package, when it suits
6) ‘Bill’: Receiving accurate, clear and timely bills, using a favoured payment method
7) ‘Leave’: Cancelling a subscription with as little hassle as possible
8) ‘Win Back’: Re-joining a service again, at any time, without re-registering.
Interested parties can download the full research report, Show the Love with Customer Experience, here.